Annuities for Retirement Income: Pros and Cons

Updated: November 1, 2026 · By David E.

Quick answer: Annuities for retirement income are contracts with an insurer. You pay premiums in exchange for benefits defined in the contract. Pros: some provide lifetime payments and a predictable budget floor. Guarantees depend on the contract and the insurer’s ability to pay; variable annuities can lose value. Cons: fees and commissions on some products, limited access to your money, surrender charges, inflation risk and complexity. Simple annuities can fill a role for some retirees, while complex ones deserve extra scrutiny.

Main types of annuities

TypeHow it worksKey trade-off
Single premium immediate annuity (SPIA)You pay a lump sum and start receiving income right away, often for lifeCompare the payment and contract features; the premium is usually not accessible afterward
Deferred income annuity (DIA)You pay now and income starts years laterLarger payments later, but you commit the money
Qualifying longevity annuity contract (QLAC)A deferred annuity bought with IRA money, with income starting as late as 85Can reduce required minimum distributions, with a dollar limit
Fixed annuity (MYGA)Guarantees a fixed interest rate for a set number of yearsFixed-rate insurance contract with surrender charges; not a bank CD and not FDIC-insured
Fixed indexed annuityEarnings are linked to a market index, with caps and a floorComplicated terms and limits on upside
Variable annuityMoney invested in subaccounts, with optional guarantees (riders)Fees can be high, and products are complex

How income annuities work: a hypothetical example

This is an illustration, not a quote. Payout rates depend on your age, interest rates, the insurer and the options you choose.

If a 65-year-old buys a lifetime income annuity with $200,000 and the payout rate is 6.5%, the annual income would be $13,000, or about $1,083 a month, for life. Adding survivor protection or inflation adjustments generally lowers the starting payment. A payout rate is not an investment return: payments include a return of your principal.

Build an income-gap worksheet before requesting quotes

Start with spending rather than a salesperson’s payout percentage. In a hypothetical monthly budget, essential expenses of $3,200 minus $2,400 of Social Security and pension income leave an $800 gap. This is a budgeting exercise, not an annuity recommendation. Use income and spending on a consistent after-tax basis, and include health costs, irregular bills and a separate accessible reserve.

If you request quotes, ask each insurer to price the same premium, start date, single-life or joint-life coverage, survivor percentage, refund or period-certain option, and inflation feature. Record the guaranteed payment separately from any illustrated, non-guaranteed amount. A quote with a higher initial payment can have fewer protections; it is not automatically better value.

Test what a fixed payment would buy later

The illustrative $13,000 annual payment above would have purchasing power of about $7,933 in today’s dollars after 20 years if inflation were a constant 2.5%: $13,000 ÷ 1.02520. The insurer would still pay $13,000 nominally. Inflation is uncertain; this example explains the distinction rather than predicting it. Check whether a proposed increase is a fixed percentage or actually linked to an inflation measure.

Before committing, write down the cash value available if you need money in year one and year five, applicable surrender charges or value adjustments, and what a beneficiary would receive after an early death. Ask the insurer to distinguish cash value from a rider’s benefit base; a benefit base used to calculate income may not be money you can withdraw. Take the actual contract to an independent reviewer if these figures are unclear.

Pros of annuities for retirement income

  • Longevity protection. A lifetime payment option can address the risk of outliving savings, subject to contract terms and insurer solvency.
  • Predictable income that can cover essential expenses along with Social Security.
  • Stable payments with fixed income options. Variable payments can rise or fall.
  • Less stress. A guaranteed floor can make it easier to spend.
  • Pooling longevity risk can support lifetime payments, but the payout rate is not comparable to a portfolio return.
  • Can reduce RMDs if a QLAC is used in an IRA.

Cons of annuities for retirement income

  • Fees and commissions. Some annuities, especially variable and indexed products with riders, can have total annual costs well above those of index funds. Salespeople may earn large commissions.
  • Limited liquidity. Once you annuitize, you generally can’t get the lump sum back.
  • Surrender charges. Early withdrawals from deferred annuities may trigger large penalties for several years.
  • Inflation risk. A fixed payment loses purchasing power over time unless you pay extra for inflation adjustments.
  • Insurer risk. The guarantee is only as strong as the insurance company.
  • Complexity. Caps, participation rates, riders and exclusions can make contracts hard to compare.
  • Lower potential returns, especially for products that limit upside.
  • No inheritance for most lifetime income annuities, unless you buy a feature that costs extra.

Who might consider an annuity

  • Retirees with little guaranteed income beyond Social Security who want more security.
  • People worried about running out of money or who struggle to spend from a portfolio.
  • Those who want to cover fixed expenses (housing, food, insurance) with guaranteed income.
  • IRA owners who want to lower RMDs with a QLAC.

Who may want to avoid or limit annuities

  • People who already have a pension plus Social Security that covers their essentials.
  • Those who may need access to the money.
  • Anyone being sold a complex product with high surrender charges and unclear fees.
  • People who can create similar security more cheaply through other means.

Alternatives to compare for retirement income

  • Delay Social Security. For people born in 1943 or later, delayed retirement credits add 8% per year between full retirement age and 70. This does not apply to every year from age 62. Compare the income trade-off with your health, household benefits and cash needs.
  • Bond ladders or Treasury inflation-protected securities for planned spending.
  • A flexible withdrawal strategy with a cash buffer. This manages withdrawals but does not guarantee lifetime income.

Taxes on annuities

  • Inside a traditional IRA or 401(k): distributions funded with pretax money are generally ordinary income. After-tax basis can change the taxable amount. RMD rules apply; qualifying QLAC balances receive special treatment before payments begin. Qualified Roth distributions are generally tax-free.
  • Bought with after-tax money (nonqualified): regular annuitized payments generally combine taxable earnings and a tax-free return of cost under IRS rules. Withdrawals before annuitization are generally earnings-first. An additional 10% tax may apply to the taxable amount before age 59½ unless an exception applies.
  • Tax treatment varies by product, so check with a tax professional.

Choosing annuities for retirement income

  1. What are all the fees, including commissions, riders and subaccount costs?
  2. What are the surrender charges and for how long?
  3. How is the guaranteed income calculated?
  4. How strong is the insurer? Check financial strength ratings.
  5. Is the income inflation-adjusted? If not, how much purchasing power could I lose?
  6. What happens to the money when I die?
  7. Is the salesperson a fiduciary, and how are they paid?
  8. Can I get a free-look period to cancel?
  9. Is a simpler product available?
  10. How does your state’s guaranty association protect me? Eligibility, exclusions and state limits vary; coverage is often expressed as the present value of annuity benefits. Check your state association.

Consider independent advice from a fee-only financial advisor with no commission stake. Compare the contract with your retirement portfolio and income needs.

Common mistakes

  1. Buying without comparing alternatives.
  2. Putting too much of your savings into one annuity.
  3. Ignoring surrender charges.
  4. Buying a variable annuity inside an IRA just for tax deferral, since the account is already tax-deferred.
  5. Not checking the insurer’s strength.
  6. Trusting a sales pitch that promises high returns with no risk.

Frequently asked questions

Are annuities a good investment? They are insurance contracts, and some also have investment features. Their suitability depends on income needs, costs, risks and contract terms.

How much of my savings should be in an annuity? There’s no rule. Many planners consider using annuities for essential expenses not covered by Social Security.

Can I lose money in an annuity? Variable annuities can lose value. Fixed and income annuities are backed by the insurer, so safety depends on the insurer.

Can I buy an annuity with my 401(k)? Some plans offer annuity options. An eligible distribution may be rolled into an IRA, where available contracts can be considered. A rollover is a separate decision: compare plan features, costs and protections before moving money.

What happens when the insurer fails? State guaranty associations may provide protection for eligible contracts, subject to state rules, exclusions and coverage limits.

The bottom line

  • Annuities can provide guaranteed lifetime income, but costs and terms vary widely.
  • Simple income annuities are easier to understand than complex indexed and variable products.
  • Compare alternatives, check fees and surrender charges, and get independent advice.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not personalized financial, tax or legal advice or an investment recommendation. Annuity guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the insurer.

Sources: SEC Investor.gov: Annuities; IRS Publication 575; IRS QLAC guidance; SSA delayed retirement credits; NOLHGA coverage FAQs.

Related guides for your next decision

For a broader income plan, compare the retirement savings and income calculator. If you hold pretax accounts, also review the RMD calculator and its exclusions; buying an annuity does not make every distribution rule disappear.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top