Roth vs Traditional Calculator: Which Saves More in Taxes?

Quick answer: Use this Roth vs traditional calculator: enter your contribution, years until retirement, expected return and your tax rate today and in retirement. The calculator compares what you could spend after taxes with a traditional account and with a Roth account. Roth tends to win if your retirement tax rate is higher than your tax rate today. Traditional tends to win if it is lower.

Updated: November 1, 2026 · By David E.

Navy and teal folders with a balance scale comparing Roth IRA vs traditional IRA
Compare Roth and deductible traditional savings at the same take-home cost.

Roth vs Traditional Calculator

How the calculator compares them

To make the comparison fair, both options cost you the same take-home pay.

  • Traditional: you contribute the full pre-tax amount, get a deduction today, and pay tax on withdrawals at your retirement tax rate.
  • Roth: because you pay tax up front, the same take-home cost buys a smaller contribution (the pre-tax amount multiplied by one minus your tax rate today). Qualified Roth withdrawals are tax-free.

This model assumes the traditional contribution is fully deductible, withdrawals use one constant tax rate and Roth withdrawals are qualified. Because the growth is the same, the modeled winner depends on the difference between your tax rate today and your tax rate in retirement.

Check equal tax rates: with a $1,000 pretax contribution, one year, zero return and a 20% rate both now and later, traditional saves $1,000 and leaves $800 after withdrawal tax. Roth invests $800 and leaves $800 if the withdrawal is qualified. The traditional deduction saves $200 now, so both alternatives use $800 of take-home pay. A comparison using the same account contribution instead would require a separate treatment of the traditional tax savings.

Example

You contribute $7,000 a year (pre-tax) for 30 years at a 7% return. Your tax rate is 24% today and 22% in retirement.

  • Traditional: balance of about $661,000 before tax, or about $516,000 after a 22% tax.
  • Roth: you contribute $5,320 a year after tax, ending with about $503,000 tax-free.

Traditional is ahead by about $13,000 because the retirement tax rate is lower than today's. Change the retirement rate to 28% and Roth comes out ahead.

What the calculator leaves out

  • State income taxes. Include them in your rates if you can.
  • Tax brackets. Real tax is progressive, so the rate on your first dollars of withdrawal is lower than the rate on the last.
  • Contribution limits. A Roth contribution is made with after-tax dollars, so a $7,500 Roth IRA limit shelters more value than a $7,500 traditional limit. If you are limited by the cap rather than by cash, Roth gets an extra advantage that this model does not show.
  • Required minimum distributions. Traditional accounts require withdrawals later in life. Roth IRAs do not for the original owner.
  • Income-based effects. Higher traditional withdrawals can increase taxes on Social Security and Medicare premiums.
  • Inheritance. Inherited Roth distributions can be tax-free if requirements are met, but beneficiary payout rules still apply. Traditional distributions are generally taxable except for any basis.

How to estimate your future tax rate

  1. Estimate your retirement income: Social Security, pensions and withdrawals.
  2. Subtract the standard deduction and see which bracket your taxable income falls in.
  3. Remember that tax laws change, so use a range rather than a single number.

If you can't decide, splitting contributions between Roth and traditional gives you flexibility. See Roth IRA vs traditional IRA and traditional vs Roth 401(k).

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, Roth or traditional? It depends on whether your tax rate will be higher now or in retirement, and on other factors the calculator does not capture.

What if my retirement tax rate is the same as today's? The two options end up roughly equal.

Can I contribute to both? Yes, within the annual limits.

Does it matter if I am in my 20s? Young workers often have lower current rates, which tends to favor Roth, but it is not automatic.

Where do conversions fit? See Roth conversions.

The bottom line

  • The decision comes down to your tax rate now versus later.
  • Both options are fair when they cost the same take-home pay.
  • Use a range for future rates and consider splitting contributions.

Disclaimer: This calculator is for educational purposes only. Results are estimates based on the assumptions you enter and are not personalized financial, tax or legal advice.

Sources: IRS IRA guidance; IRS distribution rules.

Related retirement calculators

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top